Why do builder quotes for the same extension differ by £60,000?

Three builders can price the same London extension and come back £60,000 apart when all they have to work from is the planning drawings. A planning set shows the council the size and look of the extension. It leaves the structure, the foundations, the drainage and most of the specification undecided, so each builder fills those gaps with assumptions of their own and ends up pricing a different job. That is why we run the tender for our clients at Stage Three, with one technical package going to every builder, four to six weeks to price it and every question answered in writing to all of them.
This article is for anyone who has planning approval and is about to send the drawings out to a few builders, or who has watched a neighbour or a friend go through it and come away baffled by the prices. The £60,000 is an illustration of how far apart prices on unfinished information can sit on a typical London extension. The examples further down, from homeowners on the property forums this year, show it is not an exaggeration.
On a house we tendered in east London last year, six builders priced the same package and the returns ran from £70,200 to £173,614 before VAT. That is over £100,000 between the lowest and the highest. The lowest had left the glazing out altogether, and another had excluded the kitchen, the joinery, the drainage and the glazing. On an earlier extension, four builders came back between £126,000 and £222,035. Once we added back what the cheapest had left out, the rooflights, the glazed doors, the external works and the site costs, its price went up by £28,775, and the gap was still over £80,000. The cheapest number on paper is rarely the cheapest build.
Why do builder quotes for the same extension differ so much?
Quotes differ because the drawings leave questions open, and every builder answers them in a different way. Planning drawings say nothing about the size of the steel beams, how the foundations are formed, how the roof is built up, where the drains run, what the windows and doors are made of, or what happens to the existing rear wall once it comes out.
Give those gaps to three capable builders and you get three readings of the same house. The first assumes the simplest answer to every open question, so standard doors, a basic roof and drainage that hopefully works as it is. The second allows for the worst case on everything the drawings leave out, so deeper foundations, heavier steel and a drain in the wrong place. The third puts in a rough figure and expects to sort the detail out on site, and that sorting out comes back later as extras, by which point the wall is down and you are committed.
Each of them has priced a reasonable version of an unfinished job, and the gap between them is the cost of the decisions nobody has made yet.
The most common version we come across is a shell price sitting next to a finished one. One builder has priced the brickwork, the roof, the windows and the plastering and stopped there. Another has carried on through the electrics, the plumbing, the screed, the flooring, the bathroom and the decoration. Until you know which is which, comparing the totals tells you very little.
We are not the only ones seeing this, and the property forums show it every week. This year one family had prices from £13,000 to £30,000 for the same job. Another had three for a loft at £65,000, £80,000 and over £100,000, and already suspected the cheapest had left something out. A bathroom fitter on one thread described owners who believed their quote covered a finished room and then had "another 10 to 15k to find after".
What do we do instead of collecting quotes?
We run the tender for you, which means the builders are pricing information we have prepared rather than drawings made for the council. Before anything goes out, we assemble four things.
A full set of technical drawings, showing how the extension is built, from the foundations and the wall and roof build-ups to the drainage, the insulation and how the new floor meets the old one.
The structural engineer's design, with the beams, padstones and connections calculated and drawn, so nobody is guessing at the steel.
A schedule of works, which is the job written out as a list, room by room and trade by trade, so every builder prices the same items in the same order.
A written specification, describing the windows, the finishes and the materials by their performance, so no item is left as "to be agreed".
This is where the design gets fixed. The glazing you chose for the light, the roof you spent weeks on in Stage One, the finishes you will live with every day, all of it goes into the drawings and the specification. Each builder then prices the house that was designed, and nobody gets the chance to price a cheaper guess at it.
The builders get four to six weeks to price it, because pricing a house properly takes time. When one of them asks a question, the answer goes to all of them in writing, so nobody prices on a private assumption. A builder you already know can be one of those on the list, pricing the same package as everyone else. The full sequence, from the first call to the build, is set out on our How We Work page.
Do the prices agree once every builder has the same package?
Usually they do not, and we would be wary of anyone who promised they would. Even with a fully detailed package the returns can sit a long way apart. That is quite normal on a tender. A firm with a full order book may price high because it does not much mind whether it wins. Another may price keenly to keep its team busy over the winter. Builders carry different overheads and site costs, they pay different rates to their subcontractors, and they price the risk in the ground and in an old house in their own way.
What changes is that you can see why. Every return follows the same schedule in the same order, so we can put them side by side and find the lines where the money sits. One builder has allowed far more for groundworks, another has priced a cheaper window than the one specified, a third has left out the drainage and called it an exclusion. We go back to each of them with questions, we bring the provisional sums and the exclusions onto the same basis, and then we sit down with you and go through the comparison line by line.
The package also gives us a figure to measure the returns against, because we price the job ourselves from the same information before it goes out.
Is the cheapest quote the best one?
The cheapest return is only the best one if it prices everything the others do, and on its own the number does not tell you that. Before recommending a builder we look at work they have finished recently and speak to the owners, we look at how they answered the questions during the tender, and we check their programme against the job. We also confirm that the company named on the return is the company that will sign the contract.
A high return is not necessarily a bad sign either. It is quite often from the builder who has opened up a lot of Victorian rear walls and has priced what is usually behind them. The comparison is how you find out which builder is which, before anyone signs.
Does VAT explain some of the gap?
Sometimes. It is the first thing we check. Building work on an extension carries VAT at 20 per cent, and builders present it in different ways. One quote includes it, one shows it as a line at the bottom, one does not mention it. A £150,000 build is £180,000 once VAT is added, so a quote that leaves it out looks a fifth cheaper than it is.
On our tenders every builder is asked to state the VAT position the same way. If you are collecting prices yourself, ask each builder the same question in writing. Our guide to what an extension costs in London sets out the current rates before and after VAT, together with the costs that sit outside most quotes.
Why do builders' prices feel so high this year?
Building costs have risen sharply since 2020, and we are feeling the effect in our own work this year as well. This is Money reported in October 2026, using PlanningLens data from 77 English councils, that applications for single storey extensions fell by 43 per cent between 2021 and 2025, and loft conversions by 40 per cent. A surveyor quoted in the same piece said the allowance for a loft conversion had risen from £25,000 to £50,000 since 2020, and a tradesman's day rate from £150 to £300.
So the first price anyone sees tends to come as a shock, and the temptation is to take the lowest and hope. A wide spread on planning drawings does not tell you which builder to choose. It tells you how much of the job is still undecided.
What should you do if your quotes are miles apart?
If you already hold quotes from a planning set and they disagree, go back a step before you choose anyone. Get the technical drawings, the engineer's design and a schedule of works done, then ask the builders to price again from the same package. It can feel like a delay, and nobody enjoys going back to builders who have already given up their evenings to price the planning set. However, the weeks spent finishing the information are far cheaper than settling a £60,000 question with a builder halfway through the job.
If you are earlier than that, and the extension is still an idea with a budget attached, a Stage Zero Review is the better place to begin. It is a written report on what your house and your street allow, with costed options for your house and a check on whether the brief and the budget agree, before any builder is asked for a price. It costs £600, including a site visit, and the fee is credited in full if you go ahead with us.
Either way, the first step is a free 30-minute call with us.
Frequently asked questions
Why is one builder's quote so much higher than the others?
Usually because that builder has allowed for the things the drawings do not show, such as the foundations, the steel, the drainage and the condition of the existing walls. On an unfinished package the high quote is often the more realistic one.
Will a full technical package bring the quotes close together?
Often it will not, because builders still price their workload, overheads and risk differently, so the returns can sit some way apart. The package makes them comparable line by line, so you can see where the difference is and ask about it before you sign.
Can I negotiate the cheapest quote down further?
You can ask, although a builder who drops the price on a job they have not fully priced will tend to recover the difference in extras on site. Negotiate on a finished package, line by line, rather than on the totals.
How do planning drawings differ from technical drawings?
Planning drawings show the council the size, shape and appearance of the extension. Technical drawings show the builder how to construct it, including the structure, the build-ups, the drainage, the insulation and the finishes. A builder can only price the whole job accurately from technical drawings.
How long should builders have to price an extension?
Four to six weeks for a full technical package. A quote that comes back in a couple of days, before anyone has studied the drawings, is usually an estimate of the builder's own version of the job.
Should the quotes include VAT?
Building work on an extension carries VAT at 20 per cent. Every quote should state clearly whether its figures include it, so you can compare them on the same basis.
About the author
Robert McBride BSc (Hons) MFPWS is the director of Studio : MASS, an architectural technologist and a member of the Faculty of Party Wall Surveyors. The practice has taken more than 300 London homes from first idea to finished build, and runs the tender for its clients at Stage Three.
Published 20 November 2026. Sources: Studio MASS tender returns, 2024 to 2025 (anonymised); This is Money, 13 October 2026, reporting PlanningLens planning data from 77 English councils; homeowner threads on UK property forums, 2026.


Comments